56 | Kaiaimunu

55 | Momo the Monster

54 | The Cuelebre of Felechosa

53 | Cryptid Hunter's Guidebook

52 | Crabzilla

51 | Stellar's Sea Ape

50 | El Chupacabra

49 | 'Free Day' Indrid Cold

48 | Kallana

47 | Nahilito

46 | Mothman

45 | Rochester Rat Dog

44 | Ohio Grassman

43 | Trinity Alps Giant Salamander

Wild Card | Cryptid Hunter

41 | Mantis Man

40 | Olitiau

39 | Tuttle Bottoms Monster

38 | Dewayo

37 | Fresno Night Crawlers

36 | Anomaly

35 | Bunyip

34 | Gelatinous Cube of London Bridge

33 | Hoop Snake

32 | Jersey Devil

#31 | Mothman

#30 | Ahool

#29 | Eugene Victor Toons

#28 | Goatman

#27 | Doppelganger

#26 | Bermuda Beast

#25 | Slide Rock Bolter

#24 | Fresno Night Crawlers

#23 | Hafmaour

#22 | Lizard Man of Scape Ore Swamp

#21 | Black Eyed Kids

#20 | Pope Lick Monster

#19 | 'Free Day' Felixstowe Fire Demon

#18 | Mantis Man

#17 | El Cuero

#16 | Fouke Monster

#15 | Squonk

#14 | 'Here there be monsters' Kraken

#13 | Mountain Creature Caught Running Behind Google Car

#12 | Sandown Clown

#11 | Mongolian Death Worm

#10 | Enfield Horror

#9 | Grey Man of Ben Macdui

#8 | Van Meter Visitor

#7 | Dover Demon

#6 | Euroa Beast

#5 | Indrid Cold

#4 | Kaiamunu

P A R A S I T E

M A N G L E D

T O O M A N Y

S P L I T

#5 | Indrid Cold

#4 | Kaiaimunu

#3 | Beast of Bray Road

#2 | Cactus Cat

#1 | Flatwood Monster

Beelzebub

Achlys

Moros

Hecate

Azrael

Nyx

Khione

Astraea

Zapar

Ammit

Xaphan

Amdusias

Buer

Surtr

Asmodeus

Leshy

Karkinos

Siren

Manticore

Malphas

Furfur

Ziz

Behemoth and Leviathan

Leviathan

Behemoth

Anubis

Helios

Flora

Miseria

Selene

Eos

The fight is not over!

Dollhouse Monster

Artificer Orc

Tabaxi Human

Herman pls

Murrey Krampiss

Laughter

Harvest Festival

Demon

pentagram

Perplexed

Trouble

Serpent

Ritual

Doll

Rampage

Summon

Potion

Spell

Midnight Snack

Cauldron

amused

Wicked Apothecary

Blood

Plant Growth

Royalty

Curse

Carvings

Cosmic Gore

Spooky Selfie?

NAAAAAAAH HAHA HA HAAAAAAAAAAA HA HA

Bunny Man and Langenek

Menehune

Michigan Dogman

El Chupacabra

Black Eyed Kids

Hoop Snake

Nessie

Beast of Exmoor

Jersey Devil

La Siguanaba

Hodag

Owlman

Mokele Mmbembe

Fresno Nightcrawler

Ningen

Ogopogo

Bigfoot

Lagarfljotsormurinn

Boo Hag

Loveland Frog Man

Ozark Howler

Dobhar-Chu

Montauk Monster

Mongolian Death Worm

Ropen

Jackalope

Santa Lucia Dark Watchers

Bunyip

Mothman

Recovering

Religous Trauma

Aquaman!

Dragon Breath

Yubaba

Six Fanarts Meme

Rrr-owch!

Too Many Emotions

Blathers is doing his best

cause I'm, you know...

!!!?

Sup Picante!

Isolation

Zombie Quin Rachels

Pighead

The Blue Spirit

Hangry Mileena

Beerus the destoryer

Mighty Minotaur

H-hEY aDORA~

slendyman, slendyman....

what's sleep?

Bed time?

Nightmare Grin

Nightmarionne getting ready to eat some kids

Flying

Buried

Costume

Rotten

Falling

Its all good!

Familiar

Alien noises

Time is up

ROAR

Trapped!

Moby jr.

Fear/Dark

Tasty

Dizzy

Armor

Crushed

Real Dark Magician

Quinn the loudest Quack

Gastopus

Orclass

WEEEEEEZING

It's Cupid's favorite holiday

Ghost

Treasure

Bones

Rabid

Legend: La Siguanaba

Overgrown

Burning

Woods

Hanging/Swinging

Carving

Medusa

Only Monika

Frail

Witches/Enchantment

Zombie Bear

Church

Freeze

Bait

Ring

Headless/Mindless

Nyeh Heh Heh!